HOLIDAYS | thecrustandcrumb

Thanksgiving 2026

To order, you may call, stop in, or order online. We will need your first and last name, phone number, time and date for pick up, along with your selections.

Orders should be finalized and paid in full by Friday, November 20th, for pick up on Tuesday, November 24th or Wednesday, November 25th. Online ordering will be open until November 18th. Please be patient with us while we fine-tune the online ordering system for the first time.

We are closed for Thanksgiving on Thursday, November 26th so that our people can be with their people.

BREADS

Shaker Squash Rolls $7.50/9 rolls

Butter Rolls $7.50/9 rolls

Other bread loaves available for order by request.

PIES

6” serves 2-3, $12 each. 9” serves 6-8.
Graham crusts can switch to a wheat-free almond-oat crust for $2.

Classic Pumpkin 9”-$24

Midnight Pumpkin (chocolate) 9”-$26

Key Lime, Graham Crust 9”-$24

Blueberry Streusel 9”-$28

Apple Streusel 9”-$24

Forest Berry Crumb 9”-$26

Maple Bourbon Pecan 9”-$28

Chocolate Cream, Graham Crust 9”-$26

Maple Cream, Graham Crust 9”-$26

Coconut Cream, Graham Crust 9”-$26

V&WF Coconut Berry Crisp (unavailable as a 6") $28 blueberry or forest berry

Peanut Butter Caramel Crunch Pie (unavailable as a 6") 9”-$28

CAKES, TORTES, ETC

Old-Fashioned Sour Cream Coffeecake 8”-$18

Blackberry Orange Mousse Cake 8”-$40

Maple Walnut Cookie Butter Layer Cake 8”-$47

Triple Chocolate Layer Cake 8”-$40

Lemon Raspberry Layer Cake 8”-$40

**Vegan versions of the three layer cake choices are available to order for a $7 upcharge.**

Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake 8”-$36

Classic Vanilla Cheesecake 8”-$36

Flourless Chocolate Torte 8”-$36

QUICHE

Broccoli, Ham & Swiss $28

Spinach, Roasted Red Pepper, Feta $28

Bacon & Cheddar $28

MEAT PIES

Tourtiere $32

Pork $32 w/apple, rosemary, and sweet potato